i love that area! my family rents a house at indian pass for 2 weeks each summer. it is such a slow pace. we always go into apalach at least once for lunch & shopping. i agree that papa joe's is better than boss oyster. also, the owl cafe is really good for lunch. i have always wanted to one of those murder mystery weekends, too...but i don't know if they still have them.
when my husband still ate meat, we had a tradition of stopping at tally ho's in panama city on the way home for some good, cheap, greasy food! the tater logs rolled in sour cream & chives & then deep fried & some onion rings & a big ol' cheeseburger! yummy! it is a drive-up & is a great place to stop! it's right where 231 intersects 98.